Where to Eat In Islamorada: Islamorada Restaurant Tips from Our Local Experts

While it may be tempting to never leave your private paradise at The Islands of Islamorada, sometimes the mood calls for exploring the local area. With this guide, you’ll have access to the best restaurants in Islamorada for any occasion. These places are approved by locals and visitors alike, and they feature everything from the freshest fish imaginable to steak dinners, hearty breakfasts, and more. Plus, you have access to everything from fine dining to casual beachside grills and anything else you're craving.

Dive into the unique local culture and make your Islamorada, FL trip unforgettable by checking out these top Islamorada restaurants today!

Chef Michael’s

Featuring an extensive seafood menu from hogfish to snowy grouper, along with a mouthwatering collection of wines and appetizers, Chef Michael’s is one of the top local restaurants for you to enjoy while at The Islands of Islamorada! Along with their renowned grilled seafood, you can also choose from delectable offerings like:

• Roast Duck

• Filet Mignon

• Seafood Pasta

• And much more

Plus, savory desserts from the classic key lime pie to creme brûlée are always available.

Indoor and deck dining, and reservations are allowed and recommended.

Ziggie & Mad Dogs

Ziggie & Mad Dogs features renowned steaks and a sprawling wine collection inside of a cozy interior complete with a stone fireplace. Indulge in your favorite meats cooked exactly to your specifications along with tasty sides from truffle mac & cheese to creamed spinach, au gratin potatoes, and more. The menu also features classic seafood dishes with daily-catch specials, tantalizing appetizers, plus cocktails that come complete with orchid garnishes.

Indoor and outdoor dining is available, and reservations are allowed.

Pierre’s

Featuring beautiful Colonial architecture and a premier location right along the beach in Islamorada, Pierre’s comes complete with amazing views and equally enticing meals. Choose from assorted seafood classics including daily specials along with premium steaks and other meat options. If you’re ever wondering where to eat in Islamorada, you can’t go wrong with Pierre’s!

Indoor and outdoor balcony dining available; reservations allowed.

Lazy Days

With an unbeatable location on the beach in Islamorada plus a perfect casual vibe, Lazy Days is one of the must-visit restaurants in Islamorada! The seafood is caught and prepared daily for maximum freshness, and you can choose from classic grilled dishes to pasta and much more. Plus, you can even bring your own catch in for them to expertly grill for you!

Indoor and outdoor seating along the beach is available; no reservations.

Marker 88

With seating directly on the beach, live music daily, plus remarkably fresh seafood and homemade key lime pie, Marker 88 is the perfect casual destination for your next meal! The Islamorada restaurant also features a wide variety of local craft beers along with craft cocktails made to order.

Outdoor dining and reservations are available.

Lorelei’s

Located on a large dock and complete with a cabana bar, Lorelei’s has an expansive menu of mouthwatering seafood, spirits, and an unbeatable sunset view. Enjoy your favorite seafood dishes in this casual outdoor Islamorada setting, or show up early for a classic breakfast. At the cabana bar, you can enjoy premium local drinks along with exciting live music to make your evening a dream come true!

Kaiyo

Featuring Asian fusion dishes along with expertly prepared sushi, Kaiyo is one of the best restaurants in Islamorada for world cuisine and delectable flavors. Try fresh tuna sushi or go for a combination plate to experience a variety of offerings. For a larger entree, enjoy grilled fish or steaks alongside wine, cocktails, and more.

Indoor dining and an outdoor terrace are available.

Green Turtle Inn

Since 1947, the iconic Green Turtle Inn has charmed locals and visitors alike with its welcoming aesthetic, cozy interior, and high-quality food and drinks. Enjoy seafood and steak favorites along with a hearty salad menu with the freshest ingredients. From breakfast options to late night drinks, you can’t go wrong at the Green Turtle!

Indoor dining available and no reservations.

Morada Bay Beach Cafe

With idyllic beachfront Islamorada views during the day and especially at sunset, plus an exciting menu with a wide range of fish entrees and appetizers (like mouthwatering fish dip,) no visit to Islamorada is complete without a meal at the Morada Bay Beach Cafe.

Outdoor dining and no reservations.

Square Grouper

The Square Grouper is a truly artisanal Islamorada restaurant with fresh seafood, burgers, and exciting dishes that are both artful and unbelievably tasty. Whether you want a fresh lobster tail, almond encrusted grouper, or other exciting creations like the parmesan crusted chicken, the Square Grouper is sure to delight!

Indoor and outdoor dining, and no reservations.

Bayside Gourmet

The Bayside Gourmet provides Islamorada with authentic Italian dishes from pizza to pasta along with bakery goods, a full deli, and wonderful espresso drinks. This is a great casual restaurant where you can enjoy a quick sandwich and coffee for lunch or sit down for a filling evening meal full of rich flavors and fresh ingredients.

Indoor and outdoor dining are available.

Bad Boy Burrito

With the best tacos and burritos in Islamorada, Bad Boy Burrito allows you to indulge in kobe beef tacos along with Key West Pink Shrimp in dishes that are great at any hour. Relax in the garden patio and enjoy fresh fish tacos, shrimp salads, or a hearty burrito with a variety of fish and meat offerings.

With so many great local offerings, make sure to try one of these delectable restaurants during your next stay at The Islands of Islamorada!

ABC FrisbieApril 15, 2022